Trump Challenges Court Verdict That Ruled Tariffs Illegal

September 04, 2025

President Donald Trump has formally asked the US Supreme Court to overturn a federal appeals court ruling that made many of his tariffs illegal.

Last weekend, a 7-4 panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals ruled that Trump’s use of emergency economic powers to impose tariffs exceeded his presidential authority. The judges concluded that setting levies on foreign imports is the responsibility of Congress, not the executive branch.

The Trump administration filed a petition late Wednesday urging the justices to intervene quickly, arguing the president must retain the power to impose tariffs to protect national and economic security.

While a unanimous rejection from the appeals court might have kept the case from advancing, the divided appeals ruling makes a Supreme Court review more likely.

If the lower court decision is upheld, the consequences could be severe for Trump’s trade agenda. The US government may be required to refund billions of dollars collected from tariffs, and ongoing negotiations with foreign partners could collapse.

The legal challenges stem from suits brought by small businesses and a coalition of states who said the tariffs hurt local economies. Earlier, the Court of International Trade had also ruled against Trump, though that decision was stayed pending appeal.

Trump’s executive orders, signed in April, applied a 10% baseline tariff and additional “reciprocal” tariffs on more than 90 countries, including Canada, Mexico, and China.

While the ruling invalidates those measures, duties applied to steel and aluminum were imposed under different rules and are not impacted by the court action.

Global trade hangs in the balance as we now await the Supreme Court's decision.

Other News

Follow us on social media

Ocean Freight Solutions

Flexible FCL and LCL solutions with all major carriers and alliances.

View More

Air Freight Services

Contracts with all major airlines and our own consolidation services.

View More

European Road Freight

Pan European services for economy, express, full load, and intermodal.

View More

Supply Chain Solutions

Tailored solutions built exclusively around your business requirements.

View More

Customs

A one-stop shop brokerage service for all of your customs requirements.

View More